Advocate Newsletter Andrew Seybold AT&T featured FIrstNet FirstNet opt-in opt-out FirstNet state plan Rivada Networks

Opting In or Out? « ANDREWSEYBOLD.com

Because the U.S. Federal Claims Courtroom it has made the next statement by way of Enterprise Wire: “Rivada Networks announced today that it will work directly with the states and territories that may want to exercise their right to opt-out of FirstNet’s federal solution.” Further into the press launch it also said, “FirstNet has made its choice. Now it is time for states to make theirs. Those that stand by idly will be forced into a federal solution that may or may not suit their needs or budgets. We look forward to working with the states to ensure that they receive a network equal to the promise made to public safety when FirstNet was created.”

Even through the period when the courtroom had the Rivada ruling into account, Rivada has continued on its quest to convince states to choose out. Rivada has assembled an fascinating assortment of parents to assist in its pursuit of opt-out states. It starts with Karl Rove, a well known member of the Bush administration who is reportedly visiting most if not all the states led by a Republican governor. This effort is augmented by others including Chris Moore who retired as a Police Chief from San Jose, Calif. Because the courtroom has dominated in favor of the federal government and FirstNet, Rivada is redoubling its efforts to persuade states to choose out in favor of Rivada’s providing.

Rivada has determined to forged the opt-in choice as one during which the state is at the mercy of the federal authorities and should not find yourself with a Public Security system that fits its wants. On the other aspect, I query whether or not an organization that isn’t a community operator and to my information operates few if any mobile networks, is a viable various for the states to think about. As my readers know, I recommend what I contemplate to be an opt-in-plus strategy. The plus is made up of additional negotiations with the profitable bidder and FirstNet that might transcend the opt-in state plan and supply a strategy for the state and jurisdictions inside the state so as to add value to the network over time.

In the meantime, before the contract is officially awarded, outdoors strain is being delivered to bear on the states. I assumed it could be a worthwhile endeavor to recommend some questions I consider must be asked by every state, territory, and tribal nation. It is just truthful to the governor of each state to have all the info obtainable to make an intelligent choice. Once I say clever determination, I do not mean one that fits with the social gathering affiliation of the governor or his/her employees, I mean the decision that is greatest for the Public Security businesses inside the state going forward.

Under are quite a few questions I might ask or have my FirstNet staff ask if I have been the governor of a state. I’ve categorized them by material for ease of this discussion.

Political Questions

1) Is your vendor utilizing high-profile political operatives moderately than reality to attempt to influence your choice?

2) Has your state been advised that should you choose out there might be funds made obtainable to the state that can be used for state expenditures that don’t have anything to do with the network?

3) Will the state’s last choice be based mostly on the needs of Public Safety or will it’s based mostly on some notion or promise of windfall income?

4) In case your state opts out, exactly what is going to your specific duty/value/danger be in assuring your Public Security responders that their gear is absolutely suitable with FirstNet within the event they should journey to another state or if others respond to an event in your state? And are you convinced your vendor has the assets to assure this interoperability?

Monetary Implications

1) Does your state have enough Public Security users and will there be adequate demand for use of the secondary spectrum from present business network operators within your state to fund the build-out, operation, and enhancement of the community in your state for the subsequent 30 years?
a. If the answer is sure, have you been promised a windfall or other cost that doesn’t meet the letter of the regulation that created FirstNet in the event you choose out?
b. If no, will the vendor or the state be answerable for the shortfall yr over yr for the subsequent 30 years?

2) Once the community is constructed out and there are protection points or areas where more capacity is required, will your vendor work with the state and/or local jurisdictions to add to the community to offer the required protection and capacity?

three) What provisions within the vendor’s contract will guarantee your state receives community upgrades as required by FirstNet over the lifetime of the network?

4) Who might be answerable for paying for these network upgrades?
a. Will the upgrades be achieved at the similar time and coordinated with FirstNet as a way to keep full community compatibility?

5) How long has the seller been in business?

6) If the seller fails to ship or goes out of enterprise, who
a. Owns the gear put in in your state?
b. Will take over operational elements of your portion of the community?

7) What’s its present and projected monetary state of affairs each usually and as it relates to FirstNet?

8) If a state opts into the FirstNet contract with the RFP winner the terms of the contract shield both FirstNet and each state. In case your state opts out will you require the seller to execute a efficiency bond for the full challenge value for another vendor to finish the network if required?

Operational Issues

1) How will your portion of the nationwide network access the FirstNet assets that shall be obtainable to those who opted in?
a. Provisioning and decommissioning units on the community?
b. Native management over your portion of the network that meets with FirstNet tips?
c. What can be your selection of units?
d. The same as the opt-in states are provided?

2) Your state vendor shall be offering only the Radio Access (RAN) and backhaul portion of the network, will it certify it is and will remain 100% compliant with the FirstNet nationwide network?

3) How will your Public Security customers be capable of entry true pre-emptive precedence on your state’s portion of the community and how lengthy will it take to realize one of these access?

four) Will your portion of the RAN have the same access to FirstNet community knowledge as opt-in states? (For example, would your incident app concentrate on cross-border incidents, making your regular mutual assist partners throughout the border unavailable to assist)?

Vendor Qualifications and Capabilities

1) What number of cellular networks has your vendor constructed or supervised being constructed?

2) What number of mobile networks does it presently operate?

three) For how many cellular networks does it present upkeep and repair?

four) Once the community is constructed who will probably be operating the help desk and what sort of help providers might be provided?

5) If a problem that could be associated to a problem outdoors the state’s network develops, how will it’s resolved and the way shortly?

6) Who, in truth, shall be liable for the continued operation and upgrading of the state’s network?

7) Will the seller’s RAN be absolutely built-in with the community monitoring check and trouble-shooting software used by FirstNet so problems could be recognized and rectified shortly?

I’m positive there are extra questions to be asked and answered, and the solutions must be in written not verbal type and included as a part of any RFP response and/or contract. If your state, territory, or tribal nation does determine to choose out, all the particulars above and more have to be included in your contract with the vendor. Regardless of whether the FirstNet associate or a unique vendor is liable for constructing out, operating, and upgrading your network, you have to be assured that it’s immediately accountable and capable of providing all features of the deployment. You also have to be assured that when problems arise, as they all the time do, the seller would be the single level of contact to have them resolved and you’ll not be referred to one of many many sub-contractors that may in all probability be a part of the system construct.

I have not even talked concerning the work that may have to be carried out by the state and/or the state’s vendor within the case of opting out to organize for the approval cycle that features the FCC for network compatibility, the NTIA-SAPP for what is perhaps grant funding for the construct, after which FirstNet to barter a lease to be used of the spectrum. This can require a substantial amount of effort and it’ll value both the state or the vendor rather a lot in time, effort, and money so the needed documentation might be prepared to persuade three totally different groups inside the federal government that your state actually has the assets. You will also have to prove the seller signed a contract that can provide a successful build-out and integration of your portion of the community with the FirstNet system.

The bottom line is that your state’s choice should not be based mostly on how a lot money you might have been promised by a vendor or how much political clout a vendor has, however by ensuring all the above questions and any others you will have been absolutely answered in writing and vetted for accuracy. In response to Rivada’s press release, for those who select to choose in you’ll be at the mercy of the federal government. That’s solely partially true. The RFP winner would be the driving pressure inside your state to get your portion of the community up and operating. FirstNet has been listening to the Public Safety group by way of its Public Safety Advisory Committee (PSAC) and the good work completed by it and the Nationwide Public Security Telecommunications’ Council (NPTSC).

This community is just too essential on a nationwide scale to trust to only anybody. It doesn’t matter what your state’s choice, you must be assured it is in the perfect curiosity of your Public Security group, not your elected officials!

Andrew M. Seybold

This is the previous week’s information function. To obtain present mailings of stories tales with hyperlinks to articles each Friday, subscribe for FREE to Andy’s Public Security Advocate Discovery Patterns Weekly Information Abstract, Click on Here